Under Review: The Avett Brothers, “Magpie and the Dandelion”

The Avett Brothers, "Magpie and the Dandelion"

The Avett Brothers, “Magpie and the Dandelion”
Available now
Rating: ★★★½ (out of four)

The most reliable artist producing good folk music is not Mumford & Sons and it’s not Bob Dylan. It’s actually the other band that performed with those notable names on The Grammys a couple years back: The Avett Brothers.

But perhaps the group is a little too reliable. Though there’s a lot to enjoy on “Magpie and the Dandelion,” what the album lacks is variety. There are two styles of song here: slow folk ballad and up-tempo toe-tapper.

Does that come from producer Rick Rubin. Since Rubin, best known for his hip-hop productions, entered the life of the band, their albums have become more focused, but that may have come at the detriment to the band’s wilder, more fun side. Don’t get me wrong: I really enjoy “Souls Like the Wheels” and slow ballads like it, but I could go for something like swelling like “Head Full of Doubt” or a fun rocker such as “Paul Newman vs. The Demons.”

Even without a diversity of song, the album gets by wonderfully on the bands musicianship and songwriting skill. There’s a clean, clear sound here, and I enjoy that the Avett Brothers don’t need an echoing crackle as if  the record was recorded inside a campfire or a banjo on every track in order to sound authentic. They let their unaffected melodies and voices speak for themselves.

Lead-off track “Open Ended Life” and mid-album song “Good to You” are the album’s most touching moments. Much like the opener of 2009′s “I and Love and You,” “Open Ended Life” is about packing a change of clothes, hitting the road and leaving things open. “Good to You” is about the consequences of such a life up to and including what happens to your personal relationships. It’s hard to be good to someone when you’re not there.

Recorded live, “Souls Like the Wheels” is another favorite that glows with a sparse acoustic guitar melody and Seth Avett’s quiet voice pleading to “let me go/let me go.” Anyone who enjoyed “I and Love and You” from the album of the same name will have a lot to enjoy.



Powered by Facebook Comments

This entry was posted in CD reviews. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Under Review: The Avett Brothers, “Magpie and the Dandelion”

  1. Dkellz says:

    Morning Song is the best song on the album in my opinion. All of the other songs are really great as well. Soul Like Wheels does kinda throw me off because it’s unnecessary and the live recording of it sounds empty compared to the original studio recording. As far as their other Rubin produced albums, ‘I and Love and You’ was beyond great, ‘The Carpenter’ was a little bit of a miss for me even though I’m growing to like it more now that I have this new album to go along with it. However my favorite albums are still ‘Emotionalism’ and ‘The Second Gleam’. I became an Avett fan in 2009 after seeing them live in Augusta, GA after only knowing of their existence for 3 weeks and after seeing them live I was hooked and I still am. I wish them all the best and that they stay grounded and continue to make quality albums!